The Caramba Steak House in Stirling Road, Clifton Moor, received a one rating, meaning ‘major improvement necessary’, following a visit from City of York Council inspectors on August 1.
City of York Council has declined to release a report on what officers found, in case it prejudices any future action against the restaurant.
However, the Food Standards Agency website has given some details.
The website says when it came to hygienic food handling, it was a matter of ‘improvement necessary'.
The same rating was also awarded for the cleanliness and facilities of the building.
However, when it came to management of food safety, the agency website recorded ‘major improvement necessary'.
Caramba Steak House director Dale Laverick was manager on duty on the day of the inspection.
Dale says the rating was “a bit of a shock".
He explained: “We had an issue with our boiler, this is what caused the main drop in the score.
“This has since been fixed the following day of the visit. We were told it would have scored around four stars without this issue on the day.
RECOMMENDED READING:
YOU’LL FIND MORE ON THIS STORY AND OTHERS AT www.yorkpress.co.uk OR PICK UP YOUR COPY OF THE NEWSPAPER ITSELF AVAILABLE SIX DAYS A WEEK AT YOUR LOCAL NEWSAGENT

'Why York's famous Shambles should be renamed Diagon Alley from Harry Potter'
Popular York restaurant gets one-star food hygiene rating after inspection
Club 55 - councillors renew licence for York strip club
New care home set to open in York
New padel court proposed to meet rising demand in North Yorkshire
The Full Monty Tour is Coming to Grand Opera House in York
How to Tap into Active Travel Fund to Make School Run Safer
Age UK York Nominated for Charitable Excellence Award at Yorkshire Choice Awards 2026


